Which Medicare Part D Drug Plan Is the Best One?

Which Medicare Part D Drug Plan Is the Best One?

“Which Medicare Part D drug plan is the best one?” That question was posed to me this week by a man turning 65. It is not a bad question; but, unfortunately, it isn’t answered well by many insurance agents.

In fact, the man who asked me this question told me that an agent had just told him he should be on an AARP prescription drug plan. There is nothing wrong with an AARP plan, but it didn’t fit him. After all, two of his medications were not covered on the plan. So, no matter what the plan is, if it doesn’t cover your medications, it isn’t the best plan for you.

How the Wrong Medicare Part D Drug Plan Can Cost You—in a BIG Way!

If you don’t have the right Medicare Part D prescription drug plan for you, it will cost you. Depending on your prescriptions, being on the wrong prescription drug plan could cost you a LOT of money!

I have personally encountered individuals who were overpaying by more than $600 per year! That includes premium, deductibles, copays, and the dreaded donut hole. (Look for the explanation of the donut hole in a future article.) Again, that is per year! So, if the individual stayed on that wrong plan, and assuming he continued to overpay by that amount, in ten years, he would have overpaid by $6,000!

While most people on the wrong plan are not overpaying to that degree, this illustrates that the wrong drug plan could conceivably cost you more than being on the wrong Medicare supplement. Keep that in mind when shopping for your Medicare coverage. After all, why should you overpay at all?

Why Insurance Agents Don’t Do a Better Job on Medicare Part D Plans

Over and over again, I have heard of insurance agents suggesting Medicare Part D drug plans that didn’t fit the medications their client was taking. While agents will promote themselves as doing the best job for people on their Medicare supplement, many of those put in no effort to try to save people money on their prescription drug plans.

So, why don’t insurance agents do a better job on Medicare Part D prescription drug plans? The answer is that agents typically make little or no commission on prescription drug plans. Because finding the right plan takes some time and effort, many agents would rather suggest a low-premium, zero-deductible plan over taking the time to match the right plan to their client’s needs.

Thus, it’s simply a matter of many agents adopting this thinking, “If my compensation doesn’t match my effort, I’m not doing it.” But this is shallow and short-sighted thinking. While the client is trusting the agent to look out for the client’s best, the insurance agent, in this case, is exploiting that trust.

Of course, this kind of thinking will hinder the agent’s business. After all, who wants to tell your friends they need to use an agent who is untrustworthy? On the other hand, the agent who does a great job for his client in saving him or her money in both areas—Medicare supplements and Medicare Part D prescription drug plans—will be the one referred to friends of the client, which will provide the agent the opportunity to also serve the client’s friends.

So, How Do You Find the Best Medicare Part D Plan for You?

When shopping for help with your Medicare supplement, ask agents you encounter if they help their clients with their prescription drug plans. If they say, yes (which many may), ask them how they help? (That is a key question!) Then ask them if they will help you every year? (After all, you can change your Medicare Part D drug plan every year—and you will want to do that, especially if your medications change. So, why not keep saving money on your prescription drug plan each and every year? That is, unless you like throwing away money.) That last question, especially, will test the agent’s commitment toward you. If that agent does not promise to shop your medications to get the plan that will save you the most money, don’t use that agent; fine one who will make the commitment that is in your best interest (not his best interest).

If you live in East Texas, and you don’t know how to find such an agency—one who is definitely looking out for your best interest—give us a call and see why so many others are dedicated clients of Claeys Group Insurance Services, LLC. You can reach us at 903-702-8807. We would consider it a privilege to help you find the best plan for you.


Danny NaymanDanny Nayman
14:42 16 Mar 26
Didn't take long. Got it done efficiently with nice directions on what was needed to satisfy the government and... benefit myself. THANKS!read more
sandra and kevin greensandra and kevin green
12:43 11 Mar 26
John Claeys was extremely helpful in clearly explaining the various options for Medicare and prescription drug plans. ... We believe that he helped us come up with a plan that suits our needs perfectly. We highly recommend his services to anyone beginning the Medicare process!read more
Marsha BroomeMarsha Broome
02:35 11 Mar 26
John Claeys is an excellent & very professional insurance agent. I am very pleased with the services he provided.
John BroomeJohn Broome
02:35 11 Mar 26
John did a excellent job for me and he was able to save me money on my insurance plan G...Thanks John
Melinda GauldenMelinda Gaulden
23:21 09 Mar 26
John helped walk us through the change in Medicare explaining all options VERY clearly. We highly recommend him for... assistance with your insurance needs, no matter what they are. He will review and give you the best advice. Honest, trustworthy and responds in a timely manner!read more
Libby HinesLibby Hines
23:15 09 Mar 26
I am grateful that I subscribed to John Claeys group about 20 years ago. He indivially reviewed my insurance needs and... carefully selected the best policies for my needs. During the years he personally reviewed insurance companies and often recommended changing insurers when insurance guidelines changed. Nowhere can you find this level of service.read more
Ron MattoxRon Mattox
21:40 09 Mar 26
As a military veteran researching Medicare options, I needed clear info on benefits and plans that fit my needs. John... Claeys Insurance went above and beyond—they set up an in-home consultation, walked me through all the pertinent insurance details, and helped me complete every document to sign up for the right Medicare coverage quickly and efficiently. I strongly recommend John Claeys to any veteran or anyone needing expert help with insurance!read more
Darren ColemanDarren Coleman
21:35 09 Mar 26
John is extremely knowledgeable and helpful. He made enrolling in Medicare very easy.
Ben ReinaBen Reina
22:13 06 Mar 26
Mark BramlettMark Bramlett
19:48 04 Mar 26
John helped me choose my supplement plan. Explained the costs, benefits, and limitations of each plan.
John ChertudeJohn Chertude
18:12 04 Mar 26
John is fantastic! He clearly explains how the plans work, and he made it very simple to choose the best... selections.I HIGHLY recommend!read more
Tracy WootenTracy Wooten
16:13 03 Mar 26
Lajuana EdmondsLajuana Edmonds
02:43 03 Mar 26
Mr. Claeys was extremely helpful explaining the different parts of medicare to me. He encouraged me to ask questions,... and him being able to accommodate me at my own home was absolutely wonderful. I appreciated his time and understanding. He made me feel that I could call him anytime if I had any more questions.read more
Vivian GebhardtVivian Gebhardt
19:40 26 Feb 26
A very understanding representative for all my insurance needs, comes to you for your first visit na matter where or... how far he has to go.read more
Susan IsheeSusan Ishee
22:59 23 Feb 26
Debbie VendenDebbie Venden
22:05 23 Feb 26
John was very informative and knowledgeable with his insurance plans. He explained it so I could understand it. He was... very patient with me an took his time explaining it all to me. I would highly recommend him to my family and friends. I’mread more
LorieLorie
22:01 11 Feb 26
John is always very professional and handles all the details. I recommend him to all my friends.
Wendy WallaceWendy Wallace
20:24 11 Feb 26
John is the absolute best person to provide options for your Medicare Supplement Policy. He provided multiple products... to choose from. He detailed the differences with each Company and answered every question with language I could understand.Any insurance needs I have going forward John Claey will be the person I call.read more
Loraine EppsLoraine Epps
18:01 10 Feb 26
Very informative in every way possible!! Highly recommend
Margie CraftMargie Craft
19:03 06 Feb 26
Helped me in navigating the Medicare system. I loved that I never felt rushed and he went over all my options.
John LattimoreJohn Lattimore
05:36 06 Feb 26
John Claeys is an excellent agent through whom to buy insurance. He is entirely knowledgeable in his field and can... answer any question one can ask him. He is also honest and trustworthy. I have known John for many years and went to him as soon as I turned 65 to get my Medicare Supplement.read more
Debby BassDebby Bass
16:04 27 Jan 26
John has been VERY helpful, seeing our needs and suggesting the plan that works for us. Always kind, cheerful, honest,... and gives us his best. A wonderful man to work with on insurance needs.read more
Cynthia HorsleyCynthia Horsley
15:57 27 Jan 26
I can’t say enough good things about John Claeys. He made what could have been a confusing process feel simple and... stress-free. He was honest, responsive, and genuinely cared about finding the right plan for me. It’s rare to find someone so dedicated and trustworthy—highly recommended!Thank you John.read more
suzanne kreklowsuzanne kreklow
21:01 30 Nov 25
If you need some advice deciding on what Medicare supplement is best for you, contact John Claeys. He's tremendously... busy but will find time to help you out. We actually did have a bit of a problem getting together as our schedules just didn't jive but finally had a telephone conversation to set up the new MUCH BETTER supplement. He saved me about $50 per month with better coverage. Try John.read more
barbara wanglerbarbara wangler
12:20 02 Aug 25
John explained all my options for Medicare. He answered all my questions and made me feel confident with the plan I... chose. I have recommended him to several friends. His experience with health care is very knowledgeable. Communication is quick and easy. Responds to emails/texts and phone calls.read more
Elim WellsElim Wells
23:11 30 Jul 25
My wife and I, both in our senior years, were trying to find the right medical insurance that fit our needs and budget.... That's when we found John Claeys through an online search, and we're so grateful we did! John took the time to listen carefully to our concerns, explained all the options in simple, easy-to-understand terms, and guided us through the entire process without any pressure or sales tactics. He was incredibly knowledgeable about plans tailored for seniors, including coverage for prescriptions, doctor visits, and potential hospital stays. Thanks to his expertise, we ended up with a policy that gives us peace of mind and saves us money. John's patience and genuine care made what could have been a stressful experience feel straightforward and reassuring. If you're a senior looking for medical insurance advice, I highly recommend John Claeys—he's a true professional who puts his clients first!Thank you, John!read more
Amy SimsAmy Sims
19:47 30 Jul 25
For anyone that is needing any help with your Insurance needs John Claeys is the person to get in contact with. It was... time for me to sign up for Medicare. I did not have a clue where to start or what to do with all the different options out there. John walked me through each step and help me pick the right coverage. He even came to my job so I did not have to take off. I highly recommend him !!!read more
Clara ScottClara Scott
18:50 26 Jul 25
Mr.Claeys is a very nice, dependable, and intelligent man. He makes sure you understands everything in detail and... answers any and all your questions with so much patience. He really goes above and beyond with his customers. He even checked to make sure my physician’s was in network with the insurance plan I chose. I was very impressed and appreciative to him.Thank you John Claeys!!read more
Karla AndersKarla Anders
00:26 26 Jul 25
John is very professional and concise in presenting information. He takes a sincere interest in the needs of his... clients.read more
Bob KurtzBob Kurtz
15:19 25 Jul 25
david duncandavid duncan
03:46 03 Jul 25
John was very kind and explained everything to me in words that I could understand .i would recommend his service to... anyone seeking insurance.read more
LYNDA SILVERMANLYNDA SILVERMAN
20:00 01 Jul 25
Very easy transition into Medicare. John explains to were you can understand and does all the work for you.
Sabrina HightowerSabrina Hightower
14:06 17 Jun 25
genuine care and compassion for clients . Listens and offers plans suitable for each individual. Thank you
Kevin JeffersKevin Jeffers
21:17 16 Jun 25
John was very prompt in responding to my initial call regarding Medicare and was willing to travel from Tyler to... Longview to meet in person. His knowledge of Medicare and supplemental plans gave me confidence that I have the right coverage and his assistance simplified the signup process.read more
John StuartJohn Stuart
01:19 06 Jun 25
I didn't know how to proceed with my medicare and a supplement so I did a Google search found John he had really good... reviews came out to our house explained everything I needed to know and now my supplement pays the majority of my plan B Medicare very happy we found John as are agentread more
js_loader

by:

Leave a Reply

Designed and Developed by AmazingCoders.