Supplement, Advantage Plan or Employer Coverage
How would you feel if your insurance agent told you he has a medical insurance plan for you that is an 80 / 20 plan (meaning, you just pay 20% of the medical costs) and has a monthly premium of only $164.90? In today’s market, you would consider that a good deal, right? And you might feel that having to pay only 20% of your future medical costs is a good risk for that premium.

Medical Coverage that Risks You $60,000?!!!

But suppose you buy that plan and then discover that, in a worst case scenario, your risk could be as much as $60,000 in a calendar year! How would you then feel about that plan?!

That “plan” describes Original Medicare. (For more specifics on Original Medicare, see my blog post, How Does Medicare Work?) Because of that enormous risk, most people decide to “cover” Medicare’s coverage “gaps”. In other words, they significantly lessen their risk by adding another plan to work with, or in place of, Original Medicare.

Coverage through a Job

Some people are able to keep their medical insurance through work when they turn 65. If so, this may be a viable alternative to Medicare. However, if you are under 65 and are currently covered through your work, there are a few things to keep in mind about this option.

First, it may not actually be an option for you when you turn 65. More and more employers are terminating medical coverage for employees at age 65 and beyond. The obvious reason for this is to save money for the company. With a record number of people turning 65 this year, many employers believe they can no longer afford covering people from 65 till death.

Second, even if your employer does offer coverage for you at age 65 and beyond, you could incur significant out-of-pocket costs (such as a high deductible and coinsurance) for events such as MRIs, CT scans, and hospitalization—costs that could be provide you with a much greater cost risk than, say, a Medicare supplement may offer you. In addition, the monthly premium you pay for this plan may be greater than either a supplement or an Advantage Plan premium.

Coverage at age 65, for some selected employee insurance, continues unchanged. This means that the employee on this kind of plan does not need to purchase Medicare Part B insurance, because this kind of coverage does not work with Medicare. That would provide you with a monthly premium savings of $164.90 (as of 2023).

However, more and more employers are changing the coverage at age 65 to work with Medicare (again, for cost savings to the employer). So, if your coverage works with Medicare, you will need to purchase Part B (as you will need both Parts A and B in that case). If so, either a Medicare supplement or a Medicare Advantage Plan may be a better option for you.

Medicare Supplement

Another alternative to consider for covering the Medicare coverage gaps is a Medicare supplement, also known as a Medigap policy. Supplements, which work with Medicare, have been designed by Medicare, but have been handed over to private insurance companies to administrate and to sell. (To get a supplement, one must have Medicare Parts A and B. A future blog post will provide more specifics on Medicare supplements.)

A benefit of having a >Medicare supplement plan (verses a Medicare Advantage Plan) is that there is no network. (Although there are some “select” supplement plans, where one must use hospitals within the network, this article is referring to a true supplement with no network. By the way, this writer has encountered people who have unwittingly purchased a select supplement because the premium was lower than a true supplement; it is important to understand the difference and why it makes a difference to purchase a true supplement.) When you have a supplement, you can see any doctor throughout the U.S. who works with Medicare, providing you with greater freedom of choice—particularly among specialists—than is generally afforded by employer insurance or an Advantage Plan.

(Though there is a fear among some that it will be difficult to find a doctor who will accept their Medicare coverage, only 2 percent of seniors on Medicare nationwide have reported trouble finding a doctor when needing one. Furthermore, according to a national survey of physicians, 91% of doctors accept new Medicare patients, the same rate accepting new patients on non-Medicare private insurance. In fact, a 2013 Forbes article declares that the number of doctors accepting Medicare is on the rise, a statistic also cited by the New York Times.)

Another advantage of the most popular supplements, the G Plan and the F Plan, is the low out-of-pocket potential faced by supplement holders. On medical events covered by Medicare (see the blog post, How Does Medicare Work?), your annual maximum out-of-pocket cost should only be $166 with a G Plan and $0 with an F Plan. Not too bad.

A downside with a Medicare supplement is that prescription medications are not covered. Thus, one would need to purchase a prescription drug plan separately. (Note: It is important that your agent “shop” your medications among all Medicare Part D [prescription drug] plans in your service area to make sure you do not overspend on your plan or on your medications.)

Overall, a Medicare supplement is popular with seniors who are looking for great medical coverage with low out-of-pocket costs and who want to preserve their freedom of choice when needing a doctor (particularly a specialist).

Medicare Advantage Plan

A third option for dealing with the Medicare coverage gaps is a Medicare Advantage Plan. Advantage Plans, too, are administrated by private insurance companies, but they are highly regulated by Medicare (more so than are supplements). To acquire an Advantage Plan, one must have Medicare Parts A and B, be in the service area for the plan being purchased, and not have End-Stage Renal Disease.

In general, advantages of an Advantage Plan include a low monthly premium. Depending on the plan and service area, the premium on an Advantage Plan may be as low as $20. (There are still some $0 premium monthly plans available, but remember the old adage: “You get what you pay for.”)

Another advantage with many Advantage Plans is prescription drug coverage. Not all Advantage Plans come with prescription coverage, but most do. However, it is important for your agent to look up each of your medications to see how the Advantage Plan covers them—BEFORE you enroll on a plan; for some of your medications may not be covered by the plan, or you may consider the plan’s deductibles and copays to be too high for your medications.

Finally, an Advantage Plan can cover benefits not covered by Original Medicare or a supplement, such as dental, vision, hearing, etc. Some plans may even provide free over-the-counter items.

So, what are the downsides of an Advantage Plan? First, you will find that Advantage Plans have a network. PPO plans generally have a larger network, and you can use out-of-network providers by paying a greater cost; but you will need to stay within the network for all providers with HMO plans, or else pay the entire cost of the out-of-network provider. (There are also other kinds of Advantage Plans that will be covered in a future blog post.)

Another potential downside to the Advantage Plan is that each time you use it you will need to pay a copay. Some copays are not bad, such as a $5 copay for primary care physician visits on some plans; however, you may have to pay up to $400 per day for a hospital stay on some plans. While the Advantage Plan lowers your max risk (meaning, it puts a ceiling on your annual out-of-pocket costs) from the worst-case-scenario of Original Medicare at $60,000, still, a $6700 annual cap (as some plans have) does not compare with the $166 or $0 of a G Plan or F Plan supplement.

What Are Your Options?

All of this means you will have options for your medical coverage at age 65 and beyond. If you have an employer plan which does not work with Medicare, and both your premium and your potential out-of-pocket costs are low enough, you may want to stay with it. If your employer plan will work with Medicare, keep in mind you will have to purchase Medicare Part B for $164.90 monthly premium (as of 2023); and, as a result, you may want to compare the coverage being offered to you with a supplement and / or an Advantage Plan. If you will not be offered employer coverage, your basic choices are: Original Medicare only (with a significant out-of-pocket risk), an Advantage Plan, or a Medicare supplement.

While it’s nice to have options, it is wise to do comparisons on your situation. To make sure you make a wise choice, sit down with an experienced, independent agent (one who represents many insurance companies and plans) who will put you first. For it is only an advantage to have choices if you can make the wisest choice among those options. Happy shopping!


david duncandavid duncan
03:46 03 Jul 25
John was very kind and explained everything to me in words that I could understand .i would recommend his service to... anyone seeking insurance.read more
LYNDA SILVERMANLYNDA SILVERMAN
20:00 01 Jul 25
Very easy transition into Medicare. John explains to were you can understand and does all the work for you.
Sabrina HightowerSabrina Hightower
14:06 17 Jun 25
genuine care and compassion for clients . Listens and offers plans suitable for each individual. Thank you
Kevin JeffersKevin Jeffers
21:17 16 Jun 25
John was very prompt in responding to my initial call regarding Medicare and was willing to travel from Tyler to... Longview to meet in person. His knowledge of Medicare and supplemental plans gave me confidence that I have the right coverage and his assistance simplified the signup process.read more
John StuartJohn Stuart
01:19 06 Jun 25
I didn't know how to proceed with my medicare and a supplement so I did a Google search found John he had really good... reviews came out to our house explained everything I needed to know and now my supplement pays the majority of my plan B Medicare very happy we found John as are agentread more
pete damronpete damron
16:53 13 May 25
Since retiring, I have come to regard John Claeys Group insurance services as a trusted authority. John's personal... engagement with clients is exceptional, as evidenced by his prompt responses to questions and his ability to resolve issues with insurance providers and the Medicare system. My wife and I feel confident in his service. I highly recommend him to anyone seeking expert insurance guidance. His professional approach and in-person meetings are distinct advantages.Peter C Damronread more
Linda S RayLinda S Ray
19:18 08 May 25
John was a tremendous help with my process of signing up for Medicare. He was patient with my many questions and even... provided step-by-step instructions and links to what I needed to do to sign up. He basically did all of the research to find the best drug and supplement plans for me, and explained all of it in terms I could understand. At the time I called him, I was feeling pretty overwhelmed by the choices. He quickly responded to my emails and calls and knows Medicare inside out. He made a process I was dreading into no problem at all, and I truly appreciated his assistance and his friendly, gracious honesty. I believe he truly cares about the people he is helping and wants the best for his customers. I highly recommend him for anyone who needs help with the Medicare process. Thank you, John!read more
christine hancockchristine hancock
15:38 07 May 25
John is very professional & helpful in explaining insurance. He works to get a good price & what will benefit you the... most. I would highly recommend his services.Christine Hancockread more
Harry MilnerHarry Milner
19:20 28 Apr 25
John Claey is the consummate professional who knows the insurance business inside and out it seems to me based on my... experience and he's been very helpful in setting up my insurance program for secondary Medicaid assistance. It's my good fortune to be associated with him and will continue to do business in the future. Sincerely Harry Milnerread more
Mitch AndrusMitch Andrus
15:27 28 Apr 25
Karma CrispKarma Crisp
02:10 08 Apr 25
robert gordonrobert gordon
21:14 07 Apr 25
Very happy with Mr. Claeys. He is very helpful and got all of our insurance set up. Would definitely recommend his... services.read more
Sherry McEwanSherry McEwan
16:49 07 Apr 25
Bobby BaileyBobby Bailey
15:57 05 Apr 25
Mr CLAEYS WAS VERY FRINDLY AND VERY HELPFUL
Ashley HinkleAshley Hinkle
02:30 04 Apr 25
John was very pleasant and helpful with us choosing a great plan that fits our needs!! Highly recommend!!!
Dana MortonDana Morton
21:47 03 Apr 25
Knowledgeable and very helpful
Mary GriggsMary Griggs
15:36 03 Apr 25
I thought I could manage signing up for Medicare myself. But it just raised more questions. John Claeys really helped... me negotiate the process and made it painless! I recommend him to all my friends.read more
Paulette LangleyPaulette Langley
13:55 25 Mar 25
Bill AyresBill Ayres
23:53 24 Mar 25
The Claeys Group did an exceptional job in setting my wife and myself up for Medicare program! Thank you very much!
David CurrierDavid Currier
23:15 24 Mar 25
Thank you John Claeys for all the information you gave us about the supplemental Insurance. You are the best. If you... need supplemental Insurance I highly recommend John. He is very professional and is very caring about your needs. He strives to get you the best insurance for your needs and at the lowest cost possible.read more
Deb LewisDeb Lewis
20:20 24 Mar 25
John was very knowledgeable regarding the best insurance for us and setting it all up.
Duane ZookDuane Zook
14:53 15 Mar 25
I was looking for some help and wisdom on making a decision on Medicare and supplemental plans as well as prescription... plans. I called John and he came over and was so very helpful. One of the things I really appreciated was his patience with all of my questions. And I had a lot of them. He is available to me whenever I have a question. Thank you, John. I highly recommend him.Duaneread more
Richard PierceRichard Pierce
14:28 19 Feb 25
Very knowledgeable, very friendly, very helpful. I highly recommend him and his service. EXCELLENT IN EVERY WAY.
Buck LeeBuck Lee
23:20 18 Feb 25
John is very helpful, and knowledgeable about the intricacies of Medicare. Also excellent communication and no sales... pressure. Highly recommend.read more
Kim OdetteKim Odette
23:06 18 Feb 25
John Claeys has been so helpful and knowledgeable when it comes to understanding Medicare, the supplemental plans,... drugs plans and navigating what options are best for your financial situation. I highly recommend John for all your questions and assistance with signing up for Medicare and the associated plans.read more
Mark ChildressMark Childress
21:30 18 Feb 25
If anyone needs help with their medicare or insurance needs John is your man. Anytime I have questions I can call him... and he will answer all of my calls. He takes time to explain to me my questions. Can't go wrong with John.read more
Maurita MyersMaurita Myers
21:17 18 Feb 25
John was a true blessing! My husband and I both recently enrolled in Medicare and John walked us through the process.... He is very knowledgeable and keeps us informed of changes that could impact us. We highly recommend his service!read more
kristi daviskristi davis
16:10 07 Feb 25
Gina Sue BradleyGina Sue Bradley
17:49 31 Jan 25
John is invaluable. Navigating insurance is difficult at best, but he made it simple every step of the way when my Mom... retired and EVERTYHING was changing. He explained our options AND found her the best deal. He also always responds to questions!read more
Susan RuckerSusan Rucker
15:40 31 Jan 25
John Claeys with the Claeys Group Insurance Services has been extremely helpful with my freshly-retired change of... insurance. He has extensive knowledge and the gift of explanation. I appreciate so much the time and headaches he saves me!read more
Karl WilsonKarl Wilson
02:54 30 Jan 25
Very helpful as I transitioned to Medicare. Clearly explained available options. I never felt any pressure to make... decisions before I had all the necessary informationI highly recommend John.read more
Sharon WilsonSharon Wilson
02:53 30 Jan 25
John was informative, helpful and caring. His advice was just what we needed as we started on our Medicare journey. We... would highly recommend his services.read more
Karen RileyKaren Riley
20:11 29 Jan 25
We started using John's services 10 years ago. He has proven to be very knowledgeable about the ever-changing health... care rules. He made the nightmare of choosing the right medicare and supplement policy a breeze. The best part is that he doesn't disappear after you decide on a policy. He's there for the long haul and ready to help you with issues that may arise. Highly recommend his services.read more
DonnaDonna
18:29 29 Jan 25
I am so grateful I used the Claeys Group for my Medicare questions and navigation. He was so informative and helpful!!... Thanks again!!read more
KK's EmbroideryKK's Embroidery
17:10 29 Jan 25
John came to my business and was very helpful and friendly. Answered all my questions and helped me discover the right... options for my Medicare needs.Would very much recommend him to help navigating the process for signing up!read more
js_loader

by:

Leave a Reply